

| Facts: do kids still need to learn them? What's the role of memorization in 21st century learning? |
| Editorial - Practical Tips & Tools | ||
| Written by Michael Simkins | ||
| Monday, 07 September 2009 09:30 | ||
Long before computers entered
classrooms, facts began to make their exit. In an effort to make education
relevant and reach the “whole child,” forward-thinking teachers abandoned rote
learning and embraced learning by doing. Facts were out; concepts were in. Johnny should not be memorizing the times tables; he should be contemplating
the idea of number. Now, with the
advent of the Internet, why commit anything to memory? You can google it.
Does memorization have a place
in 21st century education? Should kids be required to learn certain things “by heart?” I think so, and here are five reasons
why: focus, fluency, foundation, freedom, and fun. Let’s look at these ideas in the
context of some familiar subjects.
ReadingProficient readers are fluent readers. Decoding skills are critical, but efficient readers do not stop and decode each and every word. By memorizing basic sight words, beginning readers can focus their mental energy on decoding the new and unfamiliar words. As their store of sight words grows, so does their ability to gain meaning from what they read. Building your sight word vocabulary is also necessary in order to read “chunks” of words, which frees you to read much faster. And reading faster is much more fun than plodding through text one word at a time. MathematicsDo kids need to memorize math facts? Yep. According to the National Mathematics Advisory Panel (2008), “Computational facility with whole number operations rests on the automatic recall of addition and related subtraction facts, and of multiplication and related division facts. It requires fluency with the standard algorithms for addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division. Fluent use of the algorithms not only depends on the automatic recall of number facts but also reinforces it.” Computational fluency is a critical prerequisite to success at algebra, the foundation for advanced mathematics. WritingYes, spell checkers are wonderful things, but every time I misspell a word, that annoying squiggly red line appears and I have to look at a list of words and decide which one—if any of them—I really want. As with sight words and reading, the more words I can spell automatically, the more of my brain can focus on what I’m trying to say and how I want to say it. Similarly, the better my grasp of the basic rules of grammar, the more freedom I have to develop my own style of writing rather than be an unknowing slave to my computer grammar checker. LiteratureIn olden days, students memorized and recited nursery rhymes, poems, passages from literature, scenes from plays, and great speeches such as Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address or Martin Luther King’s “I Have a Dream.” In his essay, “In Defense of Memorization,” lawyer and writer Michael Knox Beran writes, “…memorizing poetry turns on kids’ language capability. It not only teaches them to articulate English words; it heightens their feel for the intricacies and complexities of the English language.” Susan Wise Bauer, author of The Well-Trained Mind, believes memorization builds the foundation for reading and composition skills by improving vocabulary and developing children’s ability to understand and use complex English syntax. ChemistryThe periodic table is the most important chemistry reference there is. For years, high school students were required to memorize it, element by element. I don’t know that I would go that far. Certainly, however, every student of chemistry should memorize how the table is constructed. It’s not a random array! Without that knowledge, it is a useless tool. Foreign LanguageLearning to read, write and speak a second language provides perhaps the best example of when knowing concepts and structure is not much use without the facts. In this case, the “facts” are vocabulary words. I studied Spanish for four years in high school. We had a weekly list of new vocabulary words to memorize. Through direct instruction and reading lots of Spanish literature, we developed a very good sense of the grammar and structure of Spanish. Now, many years later, I still remember how to “construct” Spanish sentences. Unfortunately, through lack of practice, I’ve forgotten a great deal of the vocabulary I once owned—the facts! So my ability to actually communicate in Spanish is compromised. Am I recommending teachers stop teaching concepts, doing projects, and involving students in creative problem solving activities? Of course not! I am encouraging you, whatever level or subject you teach, to think about what may be worth having your students memorize in order to help them focus of what’s important, gain fluency, build a foundation of solid knowledge, and gain the freedom to have fun with whatever they are learning.
Set as favorite
Bookmark
Email This
Comments (2)
![]()
Mathematics Consultant
written by L. Minton, September 19, 2009
Computational fluency is not defined by "fact recall" nor should it be. There seems to be a notion that there is a correlation between memorized facts and fluency. If there is that correlation then given all of the years of drill in schools for math facts, why haven't we ever been number one in mathematics? Perhaps the answer to that question is that math facts is about relationships between numbers and our base-ten number system. Maybe the answer lies in what we place value on in the teaching and learning of mathematics that should reflect the skills and knowledge necessary to live in our current world.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
Teacher written by J. A. Whisler, September 15, 2009
Why is "computational fluency" considered the equivalent of memorization? By having an early understanding of math facts, comprehending their relationships and identifying patterns, a student's computational fluency will arrive in various ways depending on a child's learning style. Too often, rote memorization without context inhibits a student's application of those facts. "Facts" have never been out; for some, the old methods of acquiring them were just outdated. Fact facility is a definite asset, but we need to provide opportunities to acquire that facility in more than just rote ways.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +2
Write comment
|
||



















